|
|  |
 | | Bark to Bottle, Issue #17, December 2004 |
 |
 |
 | | Dr
Miguel Cabral - cork is cleaner and more reliable today than ever before. |
 |
| WORKSHOP
TOLD OF REDUCED RISK |  | |
A concerted effort by major cork producers has significantly reduced TCA
as a risk factor for the wine industry, according to Dr Miguel Cabral, director
of research and development at Amorim & Irmãos. "Cork
is cleaner and more reliable today than ever before and we are making real progress
in defeating TCA altogether as a source of wine taint," Dr Cabral told delegates
attending a workshop at the recent Australian Wine Industry Technical Conference
in Melbourne.
Chaired by Dr Mark Sefton of the Australian Wine Research
Institute (AWRI), the workshop examined the latest developments in cork processing
technology and included presentations by scientists from several cork producers.
Among the audience were senior representatives of some of the world's leading
wine companies.
AWRI's manager industry services Peter Godden, who coordinated
the conference's extensive workshop program, described the cork workshop as "a
huge success".
"We have had very positive comments regarding the calibre
of the presenters and the quality of the science presented," he said.
Dr
Cabral said tens of millions of dollars invested by major cork producers had been
driving change across the industry.
Industry-wide initiatives include
a code of good practice and an accreditation system. Over 360 companies from major
cork producing countries were accredited in 2003.
In quality control there
has been a shift away from sensory analysis to standardised procedures using GC-MS
(gas chromatography and mass spectrometry) analysis.
At the company level,
new TCA extraction processes such as Amorim's ROSA treatment reduce releasable
TCA in corks by 70 to 80 per cent.
New boiling processes, such as the
Amorim CONVEX system, prevent cross-contamination during boiling and produce cleaner
drier cork that is much less prone to TCA formation.
Dr Cabral said research
attention was now turning to the origin of TCA in cork forests and cork's role
as a wine seal.
Transcripts of the Amorim presentations and panel discussion
from the workshop are available at www.corkfacts.com/presentn.htm. |
| | CORK
TAINT MINIMAL: AWRI TRIAL |  | | Findings
from a recent AWRI commercial closure trial support the cork industry's claim
that it is winning the war against TCA. The
trial evaluated wines bottled in September 2002 under various closures and included
two reference cork stoppers.
After 18 months, both the reference 2 and
reference 3 corks were rated zero for TCA aroma on a scale of zero to nine.
"The
overall incidence of TCA taint identified in wine sealed with (the cork-based)
and the reference cork closures is considered to be very low up to eighteen months
post bottling compared to that identified in the AWRI's previous closure trial
which was bottled in May 1999," said the authors of a report in the August 2004
edition of the AWRI's Technical Review. |
|  | |
Amorim uses a proven sampling protocol
to identify contaminated batches of corks. | | |
| TESTING
TIMES FOR TCA |  | | Leading
cork producers such as Amorim have introduced sophisticated quality control procedures
to accurately identify contaminated batches of corks. The
cork sampling protocol, known as acceptance sampling, is based on a method first
used by the US military to test bullets during World War II. Testing each bullet
in advance was impractical as it would have left no bullets to use, but testing
no bullets at all could have had disastrous consequences.
Similarly, testing
every wine stopper would be logistically and economically impossible.
To deal with the issue, the Cork Quality Council and ETS Laboratories in California
came up with a statistically valid and scientifically proven method based on testing
50 corks in 10,000.
Corks are typically delivered in large bags or bales
of 10,000 corks of the same grade from the same wash. The corks in a bale show
similar characteristics.
The testing method measures 'releasable TCA',
which is the amount of TCA (2,4,6 trichloroanisole) that the corks release into
a soak solution. Releasable TCA is a good predictor of TCA in bottled wine.
Each
group of 50 corks is soaked for 24 hours in white wine with 10 per cent alcohol.
The laboratory techniques used to chemically analyse the group soak solutions
can reliably measure TCA at levels as low as one part in a trillion - well below
sensory thresholds for almost all wine consumers.
Trials at ETS Laboratories
found that the results from group soaks accurately reflect the average of results
gained by soaking the same corks individually.
In cases where a few corks
had very high TCA levels, the group results were higher than the average of the
individual levels indicating that the group score is skewed in favour of detecting
particularly bad corks.
Increasing the sample size to 100 corks would
give a more detailed TCA picture, but it would not significantly improve the identification
of unacceptable bales. ETS comparisons of 50-cork and 100-cork samples showed
that the smaller sample accurately predicted the 'pass/fail' rate of the larger
sample. | | Next
Page |
| |  |